The Village
In 2018, protests began in the city of Atbara, Sudan. The police headquarters were burnt down by people who were no longer able to tolerate the economic failings of the state. A song titled ‘Atbara’ circulated on social media as people around the country and in the diaspora celebrated this act of defiance against the regime by honouring the city where it occurred. Yet the song is less about the city itself than about changes caused by its modernization, as voiced bythose affected by various attempts at modern state formation since the early 1900s.
The song’s protagonist is a 12-year-old boy who boards a train heading to Atbara. A verse in the song is sympathetic to his age and rhetorically questions: ‘When has this young boy been prepared for travelling and becoming a foreigner?’ He is full of hope, and his destination does not fail to impress him when he first arrives. He, ‘the son of Abdulrahim’, is from a family that has been displaced from Wadi Halfa in Nubia.[1] Now, once more, he migrates to yet another place in Sudan. The song speaks to being a foreigner or expatriate in one’s own country. Migration today is often associated with crossing borders, yet migration from village to city has long been common.
Written by Jamal Abdulrahim and performed by Igd al-Jalad, ‘Atbara’ first appeared in the late 1990s as a poem titled ‘Leaving the Village’. When Abdulrahim recited the poem for Sudan TV’s programme Asmar, the host, Tariq Gewaili, loved the poem so much that he requested permission to compose it’s music. He later contacted Abdulrahim to share the composition and inform him that he had changed the title from ‘Leaving the Village’ to ‘Atbara’, choosing only one part of the long poem.[2] Framed this way, the song today occupies the imagination as celebrating the city, in contrast to the underlying meanings of the words: the continuous displacement and movement associated with inhabiting the village in times of rapid change.
The start of nearly three decades of Islamist rule in Sudan had started a few years earlier. The song was invoked during the protests that began against this regime in Atbara. The 1990s, when the poet recited ‘Leaving the Village’, was a time of change, social and political, not dissimilar from today, or probably any point in history. Being a stranger in the city is no longer a condition of a marginalized group in Sudan, rather it has become the condition for many people living there who have been displaced.
The City
In City of Steel and Fire, Ahmad Alawad Sikainga portrays Atbara as a city of paradoxes.[3] At one point Atbara, once a peaceful place along the river, quickly developed into an urban centre, with all the amenities that came with that designation: sports clubs including football, tennis, and golf, alongside bars and marketplaces importing products from afar now that the city is connected by rail. It is easy to see the allure of Atbara and how it was celebrated. At the same time, the city showed disparities, often between certain ethnicities, reflecting a hierarchical structure that defined the possibilities of one’s employment and living opportunities.
In 1905, the British administration shifted the railway headquarters from Wadi Halfa to Atbara. This was an attempt to limit Egypt’s influence in Sudan by building a transport system that redirected the trade route towards Port Sudan on the Red Sea, creating an alternative gateway for the transfer of goods.[4] These changes transformed the small train station of Atbara into an industrial city and the central node of the railway network. The transformation had a significant effect on the villages that predated the city, as land was expropriated for the expansion of the railway, along with the accompanying infrastructure: workshops, offices, and accommodation for the railway’s employees, who were often British or Greek.
The city expanded at the expense of a small village, Aldakhla, that for centuries served as a station for pilgrims arriving from the desert and heading to Mecca. In 1889, the British administration built a military camp and constructed a station to serve it. The station, and later the city, took its name from the adjacent Atbara River. In one account, the Nubian name derives from ed (‘land’) and bara (‘coast’). The industrialisation of the city required a disciplined workforce that, ironically, later mobilised against the British administration, first demanding better working conditions and later liberation from colonial rule.
The Workers’ Affairs Association was formed in 1947 to tackle economic concerns. It emerged after the failure of strikes in 1940. The movement was undermined by the British administration, which issued an official statement that the country was ‘not yet ready for trade unions’.[5] The British administration sought to legalize the movement through legislation that would enable it to control the union and regulate it, ensuring it did not become political. However, the eventual evolution of this union made it one of the instigators of the collective movements for liberation in the country, which is why the city is often associated with protests and resistance movements. The latest wave began in December 2018 and spread throughout the country, with early actions led by professional unions from all walks of life. The protests led to a series of events, including the deposition of the country’s president, which sparked both moments of extreme despair and hope among the people. After April 2023, the nation-building project unravelled; it had been vulnerable and on the brink of failure since its inception in the 1950s.[6]
Atbara, which once attracted migrants arriving from the villages, now appeals to those leaving Khartoum. The city’s expansion can be seen on Google Maps; the patterns of movement have changed since 2023. This expansion is more obvious in the roof, many of which now include materials such as corrugated steel, demonstrating the emergency nature of these expansions. Scattered on the rooftops are solar panels. The fragility of the energy infrastructure has led to the adoption of these solutions when people can afford them.
An Argument
The song mentioned at the start encapsulates several themes, including the intersection of modernity, colonisation, and notions of progress. It also addresses how major infrastructure projects, such as dam and railway projects, have altered previous ways of life, often seen as simpler times. As a result of these changes, resilience has become the norm, whether it involves migrating to new cities for safety and work or installing solar panels to become more self-sufficient as the state continues to fail.
Mahmoud Darwish said, ‘I don’t know who sold our homeland, but I saw who paid the price.’ The price is always paid by those with the least agency, who carry the burden of resilience. The term resilience has been used since the early 1800s and, in construction, it referred to the use of materials that support structural systems. Used today, this term implies that people become the elements that uphold the system, even when it is failing, placing the burden of the state’s failure on the people, most likely marginalized communities who had little to do with this infrastructural collapse. Resilience deprives communities of their personhood and agency; against their will they are conscripted into projects imposed upon them. It is a neoliberal term that has little to do with admiration for those who are resilient, and it can be used to rationalise the system.
Similarly, resisting the system is often romanticised. Yet, once again, the burden is placed on the people who must continuously be prepared for battle. To resist is to sacrifice everything, material and intangible, including one’s own body, for a cause. It is to engage in a struggle fully aware that one will lose. In this battle, no one is truly a winner. Resistance, in essence, is a battle. It is within this resistance that much is lost; as Dorothy Parker said, ‘A battle lost, a battle won, the difference is small, my son.’
Finally, regarding return, Jamal Abdulrahim is unable to return to his ancestral land, which today lies beneath the Nile. No material compensation could restore the culture, knowledge, and history lost through his displacement. Return is not possible. Return, outside its political use, is often a nostalgia for a past perceived as ideal. Invoking the ‘Atbara’ song, which in its popular format was used to celebrate the city, obscures both the condition of marginalized people and the military origins of the city and its modernisation and expansion at the expense of the people. Return also requires recognising that past developments have dictated the conditions of today. The Sudan that was lost is the only Sudan we have ever known. The desire to retrieve Sudan is a resistance to change and a resignation to resilience. We owe it to future generations to move beyond these desires and accept that the future will be unrecognisable, that the Sudan we once knew may have no place in it.
In studying the past and documenting it, we should be aware that history is neither a trap from which we cannot escape nor a cycle we are doomed to repeat. We owe it to future generations to find ways to empower them without trapping them or burdening them with the legacies of resilience, resistance, and return. The project accompanying this text is a project of the future: it documents buildings in Atbara and proposes interventions. It envisions these structures existing in a different future, where history is contained within museums and archives; spaces that allow us to learn from the past and liberate ourselves from its burdens.
[1] For more on the displacement of Nubians watch the talks by Hashim Khalifa and William Carruthers published in Critical Heritage, Urgent Pedagogies, issue 11, edited by Suha Hasan, November 2024. http://urgentpedagogies.iaspis.se/critical-heritage/
[2] Telephone interview with Tariq Gewaili with author, July 30, 2026.
[3] Ahmad Alawad Sikainga, City of Steel and Fire (New York: Penguin, 1993)
[4] For more on the development of the city of Atbara, see Ahmad Alawad Sikainga, ‘City of Steel and Fire’: A Social History of Atbara, Sudan’s Railway Town, 1906–1984(Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 2002). For more on the railway, see Richard Leslie Hill, Sudan Transport: A History of Railway, Marine and River Services in the Republic of the Sudan (London: Oxford University Press, 1965).
[5] Gareth Curless, ‘“The Sudan Is ‘Not Yet Ready for Trade Unions”: The Railway Strikes of 1947–1948’, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 41, no. 5 (2013): 804–22.
[6] Suha Hasan, ‘Moments of Architecture Nation-Building in the Sudan-Pavilions ‘of’ and ‘in’ Ruins,’ in Arab Modern Architecture and the Project of Independence, Nadi Abusaada and Wesam Al Asali, (2025).


